Lesson 5 of 6 · All lessons in this module
- Monetary versus fiscal policy and the roles of fiscal policy
- Deficits, national debt and whether debt matters
- Fiscal policy tools and what makes a good tax
- The fiscal multiplier, balanced budgets and Ricardian equivalenceVideo lesson
- Fiscal stance and the difficulties of implementation
- Integrated cases: costing a fiscal package
Lesson 5 of 6 · 14 min
Fiscal stance and the difficulties of implementation
The actual deficit is a poor gauge of policy because it moves with the cycle and with inflation, so analysts use the structural (cyclically adjusted) deficit, and even well-judged policy is hampered by lags, uncertainty and wider macroeconomic limits.
In short
- The structural (cyclically adjusted) deficit is the deficit that would exist at full employment; it is the preferred indicator of fiscal stance.
- The actual deficit can widen in a recession through automatic stabilizers even if policy has not changed.
- Inflation distorts the deficit: only real interest on debt is a true cost, because inflation erodes the debt's real value.
- Policy is expansionary if the (structural) deficit rises and contractionary if it falls; higher spending is not automatically expansionary if taxes rise more.
- Recognition lag, action lag and impact lag delay discretionary policy; forecasts are unreliable and private behaviour reacts.
- Other limits: inflation risk, market resistance to large deficits, uncertainty about full employment, supply (not demand) shortages, and crowding out.
Unlock this lesson free for 7 days
Create a free account to get 7 days free: every lesson, video and flashcard, and the question bank. No card needed.